Newsletter
Out of the Woods? SJC Leaves Room for Local Solar Restrictions
November 18, 2026
Related Expertise
Sunpin Energy Services, LLC v. Zoning Board of Appeals of Petersham involved a dispute arising from an application by Sunpin and another (the “Plaintiffs”) for a special permit to build a large ground-mounted solar energy system in the rural town of Petersham (the “Town”), which is ninety-seven percent forested. Plaintiffs sought the special permit from the Town’s special permit granting authority, the Zoning Board of Appeals (“ZBA” or “Board”).
One ZBA member of the three-member board voted to deny the application on the grounds that the project’s anticipated tree cutting was contrary to the Bylaw’s intent and purpose, which includes protecting the health, safety, and general welfare of the Town’s members. As there was no unanimous vote of the three-member board as required by G.L. c. 40A, § 9, the ZBA denied the application.
In 2021, Plaintiffs sued the ZBA in Land Court to challenge the decision. They alleged that the ZBA had acted arbitrarily and capriciously in denying the special permit and had violated the Dover Amendment’s protection of solar energy facilities.
Following the parties’ cross motions for summary judgment, the trial court ruled for the ZBA, finding that the ZBA member who voted to deny the application had correctly applied the Bylaw’s criteria. Plaintiffs appealed. The Appeals Court reversed, holding that the ZBA’s decision had improperly preferred forest preservation over solar energy, was based on conjecture regarding future development in the town, and thus was arbitrary and capricious. The Supreme Judicial Court (“SJC”) granted the ZBA’s application for further appellate review.
The SJC held that under the Dover Amendment’s solar provision—G. L. c. 40A, § 3, paragraph 9—towns must give solar energy projects a reasonable opportunity to be built and cannot unduly interfere with the siting of such systems. In order to deny a special permit for a solar project, a town must conduct a site-specific analysis to determine whether there will be adverse impacts to public health, safety, or welfare.
Given that the Town is ninety-seven percent forest, the SJC held that the ZBA’s denial of the special permit application due to significant tree cutting would amount to a blanket ban on large-scale ground-mounted solar energy systems in the Town. Such blanket prohibitions are not necessary to protect the public health, safety or welfare and, therefore violative of the Dover Amendment. The ZBA had misapplied the public health, safety, or welfare standard by relying on general concerns about tree cutting. The ZBA needed to conduct a site-specific analysis prior to reaching a decision on Plaintiffs’ application and specifically needed to determine whether blocking the deforestation required to construct the project was necessary to protect public health, safety, or welfare of the Town. As the ZBA failed to conduct this site-specific analysis, its denial of Plaintiffs’ special permit application could not stand as it did not provide a reasonable opportunity for the construction of solar facilities in violation of Dover.
The SJC vacated the Land Court’s decision, but on different grounds than the Appeals Court’s decision, and remanded the matter to the Land Court, and instructed the Land Court to remand the matter to the ZBA so the ZBA could undertake and complete a site-specific analysis of the project. So while the ZBA’s decision could not stand, the SJC remanded the matter to the ZBA which retains a more narrowed power to deny the project
Sunpin affirms that Massachusetts law provides solar energy systems with special protection and support, but it also leaves the door open (at least a crack) for cities and towns to continue to exercise zoning power to deny solar energy projects.
Related People
Related Insights
Perspective
Unlocking the Future of Build-To-Rent Housing at the Annual Build-to-Rent Forum (East)
March 28, 2024






